Brandy’s Old Fashioned: Lake Geneva Supper Club featured in At The Lake Magazine

Brandy’s Old Fashioned: Lake Geneva’s “New Classic” Supper Club

There’s something special about walking into a true Wisconsin supper club. The lights are warm, the bar is buzzing, and dinner feels less like a meal and more like an evening you’ll talk about for years. That experience is exactly what Brandy’s Old Fashioned set out to create in Lake Geneva and it’s already getting noticed.

We’re honored that Brandy’s Old Fashioned was recently featured in At The Lake magazine’s Winter 2026 issue, highlighting our old-school atmosphere, classic supper club menu, and deep roots in Wisconsin tradition. 

Located on South Lakeshore Drive, just minutes from downtown Lake Geneva, Brandy’s Old Fashioned is a cozy neighborhood spot for locals and lake lovers looking for a true Wisconsin night out (relish tray, old fashioned, and all)!

A Love Letter to Wisconsin Supper Clubs

Owner Brian Reynolds grew up visiting Wisconsin supper clubs across the state. Some of his favorite family memories are enjoying special supper club meals. Brandy’s Old Fashioned is his “love letter” to those memories and to the supper clubs that inspired them. When a space became available in Lake Geneva, Brian saw the opportunity to build a place where families, friends, and visitors could create their own traditions right here in Lake Geneva. A space to grab a Friday fish fry before the game, enjoy prime rib on date night, or sip on a Brandy Old Fashioned at the bar after a day on the lake. 

Stepping Back in Time on South Lakeshore Drive

One of the first things At The Lake highlighted was the feeling you get when you walk through our front door: like stepping straight into the “good old days.” 

To create that timeless look, the Reynolds family spent months driving around Wisconsin, hunting through antique stores and secondhand shops for just the right pieces. Both Brian and his wife Elizabeth have their favorites among the vintage finds: Elizabeth loves a 1940s family portrait for a sweet elderly couples’ 50th wedding anniversary. Brian can’t decide amongst the vintage beer signs which is his favorite! Adding to the design includes vintage fishing gear, old camping lanterns, framed historic photos, and classic beer and liquor memorabilia. Those finds now line the walls and shelves, giving the dining room and bar that “this place has been here forever” charm, even though Brandy’s is one of Lake Geneva’s newest supper clubs. 

From the tin ceiling and cozy booths to the glow of the back bar, every detail is designed to make guests feel like they’ve slipped into a familiar, comforting spot that’s been part of the community for decades.

Classic Lake Geneva Supper Club Menu

At Brandy’s Old Fashioned, we keep the food as classic as the décor. Every meal begins with a complimentary relish tray because in Wisconsin, that’s just how supper clubs do it. 

From there, our menu leans into the dishes guests expect from a Lake Geneva supper club, including: 

• Wisconsin Fish Fry served every night of the week 

• Hand-cut steaks like filet and ribeye

• Bone-in pork chop, seasoned and grilled

• Broasted chicken that quickly developed its own following after we opened

• Bacon wrapped scallops cooked to perfection

We round things out with hearty sides and classic supper club staples, all meant to pair perfectly with an old fashioned or an ice-cold beer.

Save Room for Dessert (and an Ice Cream Drink)

No Wisconsin supper club experience is complete without something sweet. Brandy’s offers a rotating selection of homemade pies and desserts, plus the ice cream cocktails that so many guests remember from childhood trips “up north.” 

One highlight from the At The Lake feature: our Grasshopper. The writer called it the best they’ve ever had! It is minty, creamy, and the perfect way to finish a classic Lake Geneva supper club meal. 

Whether you’re sharing a slice of pie with the table or sipping an ice cream drink at the bar, dessert at Brandy’s is designed to be nostalgic, cozy, and a little bit indulgent. When in Wisconsin! 

Old Fashioneds and New Memories in Lake Geneva

While Brandy’s Old Fashioned is one of Wisconsin’s newer supper clubs, many guests tell us it feels like we’ve been here for generations and that’s exactly the point. Between the vintage décor, the classic Lake Geneva fish fry, the broasted chicken, and the brandy old fashioneds, we want every visit to feel like a cherished ritual. 

We’re grateful to At The Lake magazine for capturing that spirit in their feature and for helping share the story of Brandy’s with even more people who love this community as much as we do.

If you’re searching for a Lake Geneva supper club where you can unwind after a day on the water, celebrate a special occasion, or simply enjoy a classic Wisconsin dinner with family and friends, we’d love to welcome you.

Plan Your Visit to Brandy’s Old Fashioned

Join us at Brandy’s Old Fashioned for:

• Classic Wisconsin Brandy Old Fashioneds

• Complimentary relish trays

• Nightly fish fry and broasted chicken

• Homemade pies and ice cream cocktails

• A warm, vintage supper club atmosphere on South Lakeshore Drive

Make your reservation, bring your favorite people, and come create old fashioneds and new memories in Lake Geneva, Wisconsin.

Check out the At The Lake article about Brandy’s Old Fashioned here: https://atthelakemagazine.com/brandys-old-fashioned-supper-club/